Close Enough For Government Work

NOAA shows about 25% more ice covered ocean than NSIDC.

Look for people to be making claims of record minimums with about 0.1% precision.

About Tony Heller

Just having fun
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Close Enough For Government Work

  1. Dave N says:

    I expect the excuse to be “different calculation methods”, however I would at least expect something much closer between the two departments.

    Perhaps someone who uses that excuse can enlighten as to why NOAA and NSIDC each work with such a difference.

    • Stephen Richards says:

      Perhaps someone could explain why 2 departments, funded by the people, are doing exactly the same thaing twice.

  2. jak says:

    Steve,

    Just as I predicted: your previous posts using the dodgy NOAA data are a big steaming pile of donkey droppings. DO hope you’ll be going back to correct them!

    137% MY ARSE!

    Here’s some accurate data from the ever-reliable Cryosphere Today:

    http://arctic.atmos.uiuc.edu/cryosphere/

    As you can clearly see, if you hadn’t have chickened out of betting with me, you’d now owe me $5,000.

    2012 is way the lowest ice area ever.

    You lucky boy!

  3. AndyW says:

    Didn’t you bet with someone else as well Steve for $50? Using JAXA extent?

    Sounds a more sensible bet level. I hope you are going to pay up Steve!

    Andy

    • And I hope you learn how to compare numbers. JAXA is not below the 2007 minimum, but feel free to make dumb comments.

      • Daniel says:

        Well, not right now – but it is still a good 3 weeks or so before the typical date of minimum extent. In 2007 almost 700,000 sq km of ice extent was lost between August 22 and the minimum. If a similar amount is lost this year it will beat 2007 by half a million sq km

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *