Past NSIDC Data Tampering

This is a repost originally made five years ago.

—————————————

In 2012, I caught NSIDC cheating, just as Arctic sea ice extent was about to cross above the 1979-2000 average. They changed their measurement system using a completely bogus mathematical trick. NSIDC argued with me about it for a while, and eventually admitted that their nature trick was garbage.

NSIDCsNatureTrick

NSIDC’s 2012 Nature Trick | Real Science

They have done a much bigger cheat this time, in order to generate this propaganda:

ice at least 5 years or older, is at its smallest level in the satellite record, representing only 3 percent of the total ice cover

2016-04-22061634

March ends a most interesting winter | Arctic Sea Ice News and Analysis

From week 1 1984 to week 37, 2015 NSIDC generated ice age maps in this format:

PaintImage160

ftp://ccar.colorado.edu/pub/tschudi/iceage/gifs/

Week 38 (late September) is the week when the ice has its birthday, and all of the ice advances one year. I generated the map below of what week 38 should have looked like, based on advancing the ice age one year. There should have been a large increase in 5+ ice, because all of the 4 year old ice became five year old ice on week 38.

PaintImage162

However, that didn’t happen. What they did was change to a new set of maps on week 39, and actually deleted the directory containing the 1984-2015 maps.  They never generated a week 38 map. Very naughty.

iceage_browse_week_n_2015_39

iceage_browse_week_n_2015_39.png (1230×1230)

A large area of four year old ice not only didn’t age, but it disappeared entirely.

PaintImage160

The animation below shows what the map should have looked like compared to what it does look like. They massively reduced the amount of five year old ice that should have been present in the map.

NSIDC-week37-2015-vs-week-39-2015

The graph below shows the sum total of they did. When they switched maps, they decreased the amount of 3, 4 and 5+ year old ice, and increased the amount of two year old ice.

2016-04-22070659

Not only did they they alter the data, but they also deleted the evidence. And to make matters worse, they blocked auto archiving of the 1984-2015 data.

2016-04-22065408

The data is not lost however. I have all their old maps archived here. Did they really think I wasn’t going to catch them?

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Past NSIDC Data Tampering

  1. Anon says:

    Amazing to see PUBLIC institutions using “robots.txt” to hide things from the public.

    Great that you saved the old maps, I suppose now you have to FOIA them and wait 3 years. (sigh)

  2. GreyGeek says:

    When they hide, alter or destroy data that’s when you know they are cheating and are working with an agenda, not science.

  3. gregole says:

    Great work on this Tony. Lying liars lying.

  4. GWS says:

    Great observation, Tony! And bully for calling them on it! We need more like you! Keep it up!

  5. John B says:

    Thanks for your work Tony.

Leave a Reply to GreyGeek Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.