First NOAA Whistleblower

Many more to come…

                  World leaders duped by manipulated global warming data | Daily Mail Online

NASA and NOAA are engaged in the biggest fraud in science history, and this needs to end now that criminals are no longer in control of our government. Under the Trump administration, government employees stand to make huge amounts of money by whistleblowing fraud. Contact Kent Clizbe for details.

Kent Clizbe
Fraud Detection Services
kent@kentclizbe.com
www.credibilityassurance.com
571 217 0714

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

63 Responses to First NOAA Whistleblower

  1. Matt says:

    That is encouraging news – great!!

  2. Steve Case says:

    Anyone with a lukewarm IQ knew that the Karl “Pause Buster” paper was bullshit.

    • R. Shearer says:

      Tom Karl committed academic fraud years ago, masquerading as a science PhD, which would have gotten him fired had he worked in the private sector. His penchant for BS if anything, has only increased with CO2 emissions.

  3. Iben_Hadd says:

    There is no law that prohibits fraud by the US government.

    • Scott says:

      Actually there is and the EPA is trying to use it to stop climate realists from putting anything about climate realism on the front page of the EPA’s website.
      Bush passed it in 2001. It says – and I paraphrase that the Federal Govt. can’t publish anything that is not substatively correct.

    • Marty says:

      There is law prohibiting employees of the US government committing fraud.

    • AZ1971 says:

      Then why have government write rules, i.e. laws? Either you break the law or you don’t. Either you suffer consequences when you do, or you don’t have reason to even keep the law on the books.

      We all know the US government lies to us, the American public, but blatant fraud is indefensible when the public is asked to support the fraud through billions of dollars in tax revenue.

  4. Jim Hunt says:

    At least Mr Rose hasn’t “blown the whistle” on the Arctic for a while.

    And anyone with a lukewarm IQ knows Rose’s articles are 97% bullshit!

    • Jimmy Haigh says:

      Rose didn’t blow the whistle: Dr John Bates blew the whistle.

    • Stewart Pid says:

      Jim should know since he is a certified expert in bull shit and if his postings were spread on fields around the globe there would be no hunger ;-)

    • AndyG55 says:

      Jimbo, the Climate science Denier.

      He is a Liar and Con-man

    • Colorado Wellington says:

      Hunt, are you not well?

    • gofer says:

      But the whistleblower, Dr John Bates, a top NOAA scientist with an impeccable reputation, has shown The Mail on Sunday irrefutable evidence that the paper was based on misleading, ‘unverified’ data.
      It was never subjected to NOAA’s rigorous internal evaluation process – which Dr Bates devised.

      His vehement objections to the publication of the faulty data were overridden by his NOAA superiors in what he describes as a ‘blatant attempt to intensify the impact’ of what became known as the Pausebuster

      • AndyG55 says:

        Jimbo the con-man is never interested in any data or evidence that counters his brain-washed miasma.

        • Duke Silver says:

          If ya got nothing – you attack the man’s character. Another page out of the Michael Mann playbook. Yes, the data counts. Sorry, no – you can’t change the data. You’ve been caught. Everyone’s tired of your duping. Bu-bye.

    • TimboA says:

      They’re comin’ for you fraud boy! Ahhh….the end of such a stellar career crashing to earth…

    • Sunsettommy says:

      Ha ha,

      Jimboy, employs the attack the messenger game,while pretending to ignore that it was Dr. Bates who did the whistleblowing,making accusations that Dr, Karl produced a poor paper.

      Jimmy, where is your reply to Dr. Bates?

    • gator69 says:

      How are those lukewarm bodies from yesterday Jim? Are they keeping youir feet warm?

    • Marty says:

      Actually Jim, Rose only reported what NOAA’s John bates reported, Bates blew the whistle in 2016 and was shut down.

      Karl fled NOAA after the paper too, he “retired” lol.

      Bates reputation is excellent and he only left NOAA last year, wonder why? huh. Politics.

      The paper was objected to by some of its own authors

    • SxyxS says:

      Mr Rose’s 97% Bullshit
      is still 100% better
      than your 97% consens.

  5. Jimmy Haigh says:

    I have literally just made some popcorn!

  6. Brad says:

    I thought every objective observer knew the ‘pause buster’ manuscript was rubbish. No one in their right mind would alter good data (bouy) to match bad (ship intake). It would be great to get some internal document to show NOAA was cooking the books like the CRU.

    • AndyG55 says:

      Use FOI to search NOAA emails for where the instructions and funding is coming from, and for more signs of collusion between the CRU, NOAA etc etc

  7. Massimo Lodi Rizzini says:

    Climate change is a british green isis fraud

  8. Eric Simpson says:

    The pause is real. And it continues.

    • SxyxS says:

      Damn it- i really hoped for warmer weather where i live
      and i also hoped that global warming would make currently frozen fertile soil in Russia and Canada
      available for farming to increase food production and to replace exhausted soil all over the world.

      Seems these guys always get it wrong.
      When they make war on terror -there is more terrorism
      When they make war on drugs- more drugs are the result
      When they promise NAFTA will bring jobs&reduce poverty-jobs are destroyed and poverty is increasing
      When Messiah Obama Came to lower tension between races-more tensions are the result
      When Messiah Obama promise less nukes he invests 1 trillion in modernising them
      When Messiah Obama brings affordable care act,noone can afford it
      When Messiah Obama promises social justic the poor get poorer and the rich get richer

      Now they promised global warming and i’m really really surprised
      that a new ice age hasn’t begun yet and that canada and russia still aren’t burrier under 10mile thick glaciers.

      (can you imagine all those climate change catastrophy believers loosing this fear?They’d feel like going on cold turkey.
      Their meaning of life will disappear.
      Let”s pray that they will find something else.)
      will vanish

    • AndyG55 says:

      Yep 2016 El Nino will be shown to be nothing but a transient noise…

      Like a cup being dropped at a baroque harpsichord concert

      • Eric Simpson says:

        Interesting analogy. Yeah, I can see it that way, despite not being an expert on that.

        • Colorado Wellington says:

          Judge for yourself. The key is, don’t drop a cup of hot coffee in the harpsichordist’s lap. You’d get a Michael Mann-style tantrum.

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eo-sy-Lh2vk

          • AndyG55 says:

            The mechanism of the harpsichord basically rules out any dynamics. The strings are “plucked” and it doesn’t matter how hard you press the keys.

            Its sort of like the effect of CO2 on the atmosphere.. ZILCH

          • Colorado Wellington says:

            I don’t expect the harpsichordist would keep pressing the keys.

            I’m thinking more of squealing like a disagreeable pig …

            That’s how you’d get a strong positive feedback. I wonder if John Cage ever thought of that.

  9. aeroguy48 says:

    I was surprised to see the Daily Mail piece mindlessly scrolling thru Farcebook first. Cntl+c to here oops too late. Headlined on Climate Depot also. I copied to Drudge. Onward to spread the word Y’all.

    P.S. I hope this is true “Many more to come…”

  10. Bloke down the pub says:

    It’s unfortunate that so many whistleblowers feel the need to wait until they’ve retired before coming clean.

    • SxyxS says:

      It’s always about money.
      With retirement they loose their honeypot,
      and as soon noone pays them for lying
      they’ll go to those who pay them for the truth.

      The system is very simple.
      Bribery.
      I think it was paul craig roberts who once said,that when he started
      in the us government he asked his boss “what’s the secret of our(usa)
      political and economical
      Success”
      and the answer was:”Money.We bribe people.We buy people with money.Tons of money”
      (combine this with emotional blackmail of the karmawhore leftists who were indoctrinated to never say no as long as they can feel tolerant or good and their fear being called ,biggot,racist,intolerant etc-
      and you have the world we live in.

  11. CheshireRed says:

    Precisely the sort of breakthrough Tony and all sceptics have been seeking. Great news.

    Oh and look, ‘the data wasn’t archived’. What utter BS is that? A supposed ‘PauseBuster’ paper precisely designed to prop up $multi-billion AGW claims and the data itself wasn’t kept for future reference, thus ensuring it cannot be verified? Are they serious? How is that not an offence, either against science or the law or both? Karl’s paper was widely panned by sceptics when it came out and now the public know why. Karl should be facing jail for this.

  12. Latitude says:

    They all spent years trying to explain the pause….
    …then Karl comes along and says there is no pause

    Irony:……..Karl just said that climate scientists don’t know what they are talking about

  13. Colorado Wellington says:

    A bloody schism in The Church Of CO2 is unfolding as Cardinal Karl counts on the full support of the Obama administration in his quest for the Papacy …

  14. Advocatus Diaboli says:

    I was delighted when I first saw this news, but then I remembered the U.S. media’s (lack of) reaction to Climategate, and so I wonder:

    What are the chances we’ll be reading about Dr. Bates in the NY Times or WaPo, or hearing about him on NBC and CNN — at all, let alone in an objective light?

    If a tree falls in the forest and everyone plugs their ears…

    • RAH says:

      Remember the political landscape has been turned upside down. Though the MSM will try to cover for them the POTUS with his bully pulpit and his administration will use it and so the MSM will have to cover it in order to try and dispute the claims or just lie about them. The bottom line though is that THEY are on the defensive now.

      • Gail Combs says:

        The big problem is the Progressive Left has turned vicious and are INTENTIONALLY escalating the violence.

        First there were protests…
        5/24/2016 Milo Mayhem: Activists Storm Stage, Threaten Milo at DePaul Event

        Milo Yiannopoulos’ event at DePaul University had to be cut short Tuesday night after protesters stormed the stage, blew whistles, grabbed the microphone out of the interviewer’s hand, and threatened to punch Yiannopoulos in the face…
        Black Lives Matter Activist Takes A Swing At Milo…
        (wwwDOT)breitbart.com/tech/2016/05/24/milo-yiannopoulos-protesters-storm-stage-depaul-university/

        Then massive PLANNED RIOTS
        Anti-Fascists’ Plan to ‘Shut Down’ MILO’s Event at UC Berkeley
        (wwwDOT)breitbart.com/milo/2017/01/31/anti-fascists-plan-shut-milos-event-uc-berkeley/

        And of course they did, with the help of Stand Down orders to the campus police.
        MILO Security Coordinator: Berkeley Police Had a ‘No Arrests Policy’

        This violence is not new to Universities.
        12/14/2014 CUNY Professor Arrested For Assaulting Cops At Millions March NYC

        …Eric Linsker has been hit with seven charges—including robbery, assault on a police officer, rioting, resisting arrest, reckless endangerment, obstructing government administration, and unlawful possession of marijuana…

        [He] “punched and kicked the lieutenants while attempting to remove their NYPD jackets and radios.” [His] backpack, which cops say had a ski mask, three hammers wrapped in plastic, and other “personal items.” They were able to track Linsker down because of the backpack, though it wasn’t clear exactly how…

        Other articles say the hammers were recently purchased.
        …………

        Hammers and masks are used by Black Bloc Members such as those who have shown up in Europe and at Trump’s inauguration and then at Milo’s Berzerkley event.

        …Black Bloc members organize themselves using social media. the group was well prepared ahead of the march with hammers, crowbars, long poles and flares to use in vandalism attacks on buildings and confrontations with police.
        (wwwDOT)wusa9.com/news/local/inside-the-black-bloc-the-most-extreme-elements-of-anti-trumpism/391602657

        >>>>>>>>>>>

        Now it has become targeted:
        Antifa Threatens Young Daughter of Pro-Trump Journalist

        Targeted Attack On At Least Seven Indianapolis Area Officer’s Homes In One Night

        …Squad cars that were parked in front of homes had their windows broken and their tires were slashed. Alarmingly, those whose cars weren’t home still had vandalism done to their property, including graffiti on their garage doors. The graffiti included “F**k WPD (Whitestown Police Department).” At this time only police officer’s homes are believed to be the target….

        Eight Years of Obummer and City officials that give destructive Ferals the green light has set the USA up for a need of some major disciplinary action. Unfortunately this will give the Uncivilized brats even more reason to scream and throw tantrums since The Rule of Law’ is a completely foreign concept to them.

        “We also gave those who wished to destroy space to do that as well” ~ Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake Apr 28, 2015

        Perhaps sitting in a jail cell for ten years will smarten these brats up.

  15. Oliver K. Manuel says:

    Thanks for this story, Tony.

    Trump’s most effective next move to end 71-years of obviously false “consensus science” would be to ask his Science Advisor and the NAS President to admit or deny publicly the logical error in Dr. Carl Von Weizsacker’s 1935 definition of nuclear binding energy.”

    That error was inserted into major nuclear physics textbooks worldwide after WWII, although a 19-year old student had recognized the error on 13 June 1936 and risked the rest of his life after WWII showing how this mistake isolated humanity from reality: The Sun made, sustains and holds every atom, life and planet in the solar system in continuous vibration.

    See: PAUL KAZUO KURODA (1917-2001)

    1. Autobiography: http://www.omatumr.com/abstracts2005/PKKAutobiography.pdf

    2. Recent tribute: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/10640850/TRIBUTE_TO_KURODA.pdf

  16. AndyG55 says:

    Yep 2016 El Nino will be shown to be nothing but a transient noise in a baroque harpsichord concert.

  17. Frank K. says:

    Here’s the story from Dr. Bates himself. READ IT ALL…

    https://judithcurry.com/2017/02/04/climate-scientists-versus-climate-data/

    A sample:

    “I questioned another co-author about why they choose to use a 90% confidence threshold for evaluating the statistical significance of surface temperature trends, instead of the standard for significance of 95% — he also expressed reluctance and did not defend the decision. A NOAA NCEI supervisor remarked how it was eye-opening to watch Karl work the co-authors, mostly subtly but sometimes not, pushing choices to emphasize warming. Gradually, in the months after K15 came out, the evidence kept mounting that Tom Karl constantly had his ‘thumb on the scale’—in the documentation, scientific choices, and release of datasets—in an effort to discredit the notion of a global warming hiatus and rush to time the publication of the paper to influence national and international deliberations on climate policy.

    • AndyG55 says:

      As I think I have mentioned, the fact that NONE of the co-writers seem to have the code or the data means that NONE of them could have actually checked Tom Karl’s work.

      Seems he has bullied them into signing unknown work

      If so, that is totally disgraceful from him and from his co-writers.

  18. GoFigure says:

    This article also talks about a positive rate of warming beginning in the 50s !

    What the hell happened to the COOLING from the 1940s to 1975?

  19. pseudo-intellectual says:

    http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/feb/6/noaa-agrees-review-claim-data-manipulation-climate/

    NOAA agrees to review its data… but will it be an independent review?

  20. Jim Hunt says:

    I gave ex Prof. Judy an exclusive on this GWC news release for today (UTC). Now all can be revealed in here!

    Speaking from their Ivory Towers near the North Pole, Great White Con spokesperson Snow White announced by the light of the silvery moon:

    We are extremely proud to have been selected as Feedspot’s 21st best Global Warming blog on the web. Whilst it’s galling to be below WUWT we’re well ahead of the GWPF and Climate Etc. is nowhere to be seen. [And neither is Deplorable Client Science – Mod]

    By way of celebration we have some Shock News to impart!

    http://GreatWhiteCon.info/2017/02/beta-testing-snow-whites-alternate-fact-detector/

    We flipped the switch on the first beta test version of Snow White’s Alternative Facts Wetware™ (AFW™ for short) AF detection subsystem early on Saturday morning (UTC). We were astonished when the needle literally flew past the end stops later that morning. Initially we suspected a bug must have sneaked in via one of Snow’s unprotected ear canals. However when she rather reluctantly ran her exhaustive diagnostic routines they revealed that her mission was in actual fact absolutely nominal.

    What happened next therefore came as no surprise whatsoever.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.