Debate heats up over IPCC melting glaciers claim
Glaciologists are this week arguing over how a highly contentious claim about the speed at which glaciers are melting came to be included in the latest report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
In 1999 New Scientist reported a comment by the leading Indian glaciologist Syed Hasnain, who said in an email interview with this author that all the glaciers in the central and eastern Himalayas could disappear by 2035.
Hasnain, of Jawaharlal Nehru University in Delhi, who was then chairman of the International Commission on Snow and Ice’s working group on Himalayan glaciology, has never repeated the prediction in a peer-reviewed journal. He now says the comment was “speculative”.
Despite the 10-year-old New Scientist report being the only source, the claim found its way into the IPCC fourth assessment report published in 2007. Moreover the claim was extrapolated to include all glaciers in the Himalayas.
Debate heats up over IPCC melting glaciers claim – environment – 08 January 2010 – New Scientist
James Delingpole explains the IPCC methodology :
So, to recap: in the course of a garbled phone conversation a scientist accidentally invents a problem that doesn’t exist. This gets reported as if gospel in an influential Warmist science magazine and repeated by a Warmist NGO, before being lent the full authority of the IPCC’s fourth assessment report which, as we know, can’t be wrong because it is vetted by around 2,500 scientists. Then, on the back of this untrue story, the scientist gets a cushy job at the institution whose director is also in charge of the IPCC.
Syed Hasnain, RK Pachauri and the mystery of the non-disappearing glaciers – Telegraph Blogs
They won’t do that again, will they? /sarc
Jobs for the boys!
I predict that global climate change will turn Australia into a desert landscape by 2030.
Can I get a cushy job and a grant now too? Oh that’s right. We just sacked Tim Flannery for saying crap like that……..
Reblogged this on Edonurwayup's Blog and commented:
We need to find all the cracks in the armor and fill them with C4.
It’s science Jim but not as we know it.