The first six months of 2014 were the second coldest on record in Illinois.
Changing station composition (loss of rural stations) likely skews recent temperatures too high. NOAA adjusts for these spuriously high temperatures, by making them even higher through the use of infilling and gridding – thus transforming rural stations into urban ones.
Anthony Watts wrote over on his site that I said
Goddard initially claimed 40% of the STATIONS were missing
This is the line Anthony is referring to, from his original E-mail
This claim: “More than 40% of USHCN final station data is now generated from stations which have no thermometer data.”
Is utterly bogus.
I didn’t say the stations were missing. I said they had no thermometer data, which is exactly what is happening. Every month in 2014, about 40% of the stations have no thermometer data. Basic grammar tells us that you can’t “have” something if you don’t exist. And I had actually altered the text to make it less ambiguous before Anthony sent over the E-mail. Then Anthony went on a rampage attacking me all over the Internet, over something which there was never any question I was correct about.
Anthony frequently thinks I am “making mistakes”, because he reads into my words concepts which I didn’t say (confirmation bias.) It is important to read people’s words carefully, rather than shooting from the hip. Anthony finished that E-Mail with the words.
YOU NEED TO DO BETTER.
I couldn’t have said it better. I do very much appreciate Anthony’s post from yesterday to clarify the situation. It shows that he is an honorable man.
[youtube=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2f-MZ2HRHQ]
A national tax on anything that produces carbon emissions — gasoline, airplanes and coal-burning power plants — is the goal of the new Kentucky chapter of Citizens’ Climate Lobby, an international nonprofit group seeking to curb global warming.
Humans exhale a terrifying 40,000 PPM CO2 – enough to raise current atmospheric CO2 levels by 100X. In order to rescue mankind from global warming, breathing must be stopped through taxation or whatever other means is necessary.
Obama lambastes climate change deniers as ‘radical fringe’ in California speech
According to the latest Pew Poll, only 40% of Americans believe that global warming is caused by human activity, meaning that the president considers 60% of Americans to be a “radical fringe”
With the borders open for terrorists to walk across, government paramilitary units are invading 124 American homes per night
Nestled awkwardly among the usual guff, the outrage website Salon this week took a welcome flyer and accorded space to something genuinely alarming. “A SWAT team,” the headline screamed, “blew a hole in my 2-year-old son.” For once, this wasn’t hyperbole.
Paramilitary operations, the ACLU concluded, are “happening in about 124 homes every day — or more likely every night” — and four in five of those are performed in order that authorities might “search homes, usually for drugs.” Such raids routinely involve “armored personnel carriers,” “military equipment like battering rams,” and “flashbang grenades.”
[youtube=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tt2yGzHfy7s]
Last year, temperatures north of 80N were below normal every single day, and so far a repeat in 2014. It is difficult to make the Arctic ice free with a melt season of four weeks at 1ºC.
COI | Centre for Ocean and Ice | Danmarks Meteorologiske Institut
I just took an amazing walk through the forest and got to a clearing where there were probably a thousand fireflies flashing every second, against an almost pitch black background. Simply incredible sight. Like the 4th of July.
It is unfortunate that people have been trained to rot their brains out getting propagandized by TV, rather than going outside and enjoying all the amazing gifts God has created for us.
The world would be a much better place if everyone shot their television, and got back in touch with the real world.
I want to know how God created this world. I am not interested in this or that phenomenon, in the spectrum of this or that element. I want to know His thoughts; the rest are details.
– Albert Einstein
My religion consists of a humble admiration of the illimitable superior spirit who reveals himself in the slight details we are able to perceive with our frail and feeble mind.
– Albert Einstein
The scientists’ religious feeling takes the form of a rapturous amazement at the harmony of natural law, which reveals an intelligence of such superiority that, compared with it, all the systematic thinking and acting of human beings is an utterly insignificant reflection.
– Albert Einstein
Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind.
– Albert Einstein
According to the USHCN V1 docs, they were done adjusting after 1990.
According to the V2 specs, they use the same TOBS algorithm as in V1. So it seems safe to assume that stations with no missing data after 1990 need no adjustments.
1990 was also the year when they started exponentially losing station data, and started doing a lot of infilling.
So I did an experiment. I calculated the post-1990 measured temperatures for all stations with no missing data, and the post 1990 temperatures for all of the fabricated data. The fake data is diverging from the real station data at a phenomenal 5.3 degrees per century.
That huge spike in temperatures after 1990 which NCDC shows (and I asked you to bookmark last night) is almost entirely due to fake data. Unbelievable.
I’ve been talking about the discontinuity after 1990 for a long time, and there you have it.
I have been emphasizing the difference between commercial and government software.
Commercial software goes through constant review. Mine gets reviewed 2-3 times a day by my boss.
Government software on the other hand has no quality control. Consider the Obamacare web site or the just announced USHCN software disaster.
The scientific method is at work on the USHCN temperature data set | Watts Up With That?
A bunch of scientists with no software training cranking out code, with the only review process being that the output confirms their biases. The error USHCN has uncovered is so blatant, that it obviously has never been through any kind of serious verification.
They were just happy to see a lot of warming, and it didn’t matter that global warming research, climate models, and US domestic policy in Washington were based on their graphs. It wasn’t worth spending two hours doing any verification.
Zeke just can’t grasp what he is doing wrong. Around 1990, USHCN started losing a lot of mainly rural stations. Using their clever infilling and gridding, they turned those disappearing stations into urban stations – which created a huge spurious warming trend.
Zeke likes the meaningless green line.
See the graph below. Essentially all of the warming since 1990 is due to fabricated (no underlying temperature records) data shown below in green – which strongly hints at cooler rural stations being lost, and their missing data being replaced by infilled urban data.
This is so blatantly obvious, that only a temperature expert couldn’t grasp it.
It is like dealing with anomaly/infilling/gridding zombies. Do they actually think that their large spike in temperatures after 1990, coinciding with their large spike in lost (mainly rural) stations – was coincidence?
If you lose a cool rural station and replace the data with that from a warm urban station, it raises your average temperature. Now repeat over and over again several hundred times since 1990.
In the next graph, I normalized Zekes data properly, and highlighted the period of rapid station loss in blue. The huge spike in temperatures in the green line is due to garbage data handling practices, not warming.
Just say no to data tampering. This nonsense has to come to an end.
