Real Climate Science

I created another visual aid to help people understand what our top climate scientists see as unprecedented unpresidented global warming.

“When men choose not to believe in God, they do not thereafter believe in nothing, they then become capable of believing in anything.”

• G K Chesterton

If the Mt Pinatubo cooling is removed, there has been almost no warming since the 1990 IPCC report was published. Also note that last years’ warmth was almost entirely due to El Nino, and government claims to the contrary were fraudulent.

Wood for Trees: Interactive Graphs

Also note that the IPCC report showed very little warming prior to 1990, and that all of that occurred before 1950.

Chapter 7

Global warming is the biggest science scam in history. It is due almost entirely to the mishandling of climate data by NASA and NOAA.

Gavin says my graph is fake.

I generated the graph from Gavin’s own data on the same NASA web page Gavin linked to. Apparently the primary person in charge of creating the propaganda behind the trillion dollar global warming scam is unfamiliar with his own data.

Link to NASA files  2016   2000

Here is the spreadsheet   2016_01_v3_GLB.Ts.xls

(Note : there was an error in my original graphs due to years being shifted by one. That caused some jitter and slightly increased discrepancy which is corrected in the graphs and spreadsheet here)

Satellites show little or no warming during the 16 years from 2000 to 2016 when Gavin has increased warming by 2.5X.

Wood for Trees: Interactive Graphs

Also note the optical illusion Gavin employs. The lines appear very close inside the circle.

But there is actually a very large change from 2000 to 2016.

Here is Gavin’s data :

2000 Version:

                 GLOBAL Temperature Anomalies in deg C     base period: 1951-1980
     
                    sources: GHCN 1701-12/2000 (meteorological stations only)
                    using elimination of outliers and homogeneity adjustment
                    Notes: 1941 DJF = Dec 1940 - Feb 1941 ;  ***** = missing
     
Year   Jan   Feb   Mar   Apr   May   Jun   Jul   Aug   Sep   Oct     Nov   Dec     J-D   D-N   DJF   MAM   JJA   SON
1867  -.37   .02  -.95   .41  -.01   .46   .23   .12   .23   .54     .07   .43      .1     *     *  -.18   .27   .28
1868 -1.01  -.83   .32   .09   .07   .22   .09  -.29  -.01   .27    -.51  -.06    -.14   -.1  -.47   .16   .01  -.09
1869   .23   .32  -.04    .1  -.34   .21   .16   .32  -.12  -.27     .06   .23     .07   .05   .17   -.1   .23  -.11
1870   .34  -.26  -.61  -.03  -.04    .2  -.11  -.56  -.18  -.05     .02  -.75    -.17  -.09   .11  -.23  -.16  -.07
1871   -.4  -.36  -.29   .03  -.19  -.13  -.11   .11  -.15   -.4    -.34   .18    -.17  -.25   -.5  -.15  -.05   -.3
1872   .33   .34  -.13  -.14   .05   .42   .06  -.84  -.04  -.25    -.07  -.46    -.06  -.01   .28  -.08  -.12  -.12
1873   -.7  -.31  -.21  -.48  -.09   .52  -.49   .41   -.2   .38    -.73   .33    -.13   -.2  -.49  -.26   .15  -.18
1874   .27  -.31   -.1   .16  -.29  -.39  -.09  -.25  -.41   .11     -.3   .15    -.12  -.11   .09  -.08  -.25   -.2
1875  -.11  -.44  -.48  -.09  -.07   .22    .2    .2  -.38  -.13    -.59  -.47    -.18  -.13  -.13  -.22   .21  -.36
1876    .1  -.17   .26  -.14  -.44  -.18  -.31  -.39  -.25   .29    -.16  -.09    -.12  -.15  -.18  -.11  -.29  -.04
1877  -.08   .28  -.11  -.29  -.49   .02   .28   .55  -.13  -.15      .3   .51     .06   .01   .03   -.3   .29   .01
1878   .27   .41   .95   .56  -.33  -.07   .04   .02   .48   .43     .22  -.05     .24   .29    .4   .39    .0   .38
1879   .03  -.32    .0  -.33  -.29  -.67  -.55   -.2  -.09    .0    -.26  -.54    -.27  -.23  -.11  -.21  -.47  -.12
1880   .26   .08  -.11  -.15  -.13  -.55   -.2   .03   .05  -.42    -.32  -.02    -.12  -.17  -.07  -.13  -.24  -.23
1881  -.53  -.05  -.13    .1    .2  -.82  -.03  -.08  -.16  -.18    -.17   .28    -.13  -.16   -.2   .05  -.31  -.17
1882   .76   .43   .26  -.31  -.12  -.62  -.52  -.19   .23  -.13      .1    .0    -.01   .01   .49  -.06  -.44   .07
1883  -.16  -.53  -.05   .18   .01   .56   .21  -.01   -.3  -.17    -.39   .13    -.04  -.05  -.23   .05   .25  -.28
1884   -.2    .1  -.26  -.74  -.74  -.44  -.54  -.11  -.23  -.42    -.61  -.85    -.42  -.34   .01  -.58  -.36  -.42
1885  -.59  -.45  -.56  -.49  -.39  -.58  -.12   .08  -.12   .21    -.27   .34    -.24  -.34  -.63  -.48  -.21  -.06
1886  -.49  -.46  -.44  -.17  -.18  -.17  -.12  -.22  -.25  -.67     .01  -.19    -.28  -.23   -.2  -.26  -.17   -.3
1887  -.55  -.82  -.26  -.41  -.46  -.66  -.23  -.37  -.52  -.29    -.73  -.25    -.46  -.46  -.52  -.38  -.42  -.51
1888  -.37  -.57  -.64  -.06  -.41  -.24  -.33  -.32  -.34  -.04     .32    .1    -.24  -.27  -.39  -.37   -.3  -.02
1889   .17    .4   .23   .32   .31  -.01  -.34  -.31  -.23   .03    -.22   .07     .03   .04   .22   .29  -.22  -.14
1890  -.17  -.38  -.14  -.07  -.29  -.04  -.43   -.2  -.03  -.07    -.58  -.26    -.22  -.19  -.16  -.17  -.22  -.23
1891  -.79 -1.05  -.49  -.65  -.23   -.5   -.8  -.63  -.47  -.66    -.34  -.11    -.56  -.57   -.7  -.46  -.64  -.49
1892  -.51  -.08  -.45  -.72  -.48   -.4  -.31  -.14  -.42  -.41     -.4  -.51     -.4  -.37  -.23  -.55  -.28  -.41
1893 -1.54  -.79  -.44  -.28  -.44  -.45  -.04    .0  -.19   .24    -.29  -.48    -.39  -.39  -.94  -.39  -.16  -.08
1894  -.62  -.63  -.19  -.47   -.5  -.31   -.3  -.32  -.55  -.08    -.05  -.03    -.34  -.38  -.58  -.39  -.31  -.23
1895  -.53  -.88  -.48   -.5  -.26  -.24  -.62  -.22  -.17  -.02    -.01  -.01    -.33  -.33  -.48  -.41  -.36  -.07
1896   .03  -.22  -.47  -.42  -.48  -.38   -.3  -.47  -.22   .14    -.38  -.12    -.27  -.27  -.07  -.46  -.38  -.15
1897  -.13  -.26  -.33   .09  -.06  -.27   .15  -.26  -.23  -.43    -.03  -.06    -.15  -.16  -.17   -.1  -.13  -.23
1898   .23  -.32  -.57  -.34  -.53  -.23  -.08   .11   .02  -.44    -.31  -.17    -.22  -.21  -.05  -.48  -.07  -.24
1899  -.43  -.37  -.15  -.32  -.51  -.26  -.34  -.28  -.03   -.3     .11  -.15    -.25  -.25  -.32  -.33  -.29  -.07
1900  -.43  -.06   .01  -.07   .04   .13  -.18  -.13  -.08   .17    -.09  -.05    -.06  -.07  -.21  -.01  -.06    .0
1901  -.15  -.08  -.05   .07  -.02   .12  -.27  -.06   .05  -.04    -.08  -.18    -.06  -.05  -.09    .0  -.07  -.02
1902  -.29  -.03  -.06  -.18  -.28  -.28  -.32  -.47  -.44  -.38    -.41  -.52     -.3  -.28  -.17  -.17  -.36  -.41
1903  -.27  -.13  -.07  -.48  -.38   -.6  -.23  -.38  -.44  -.51    -.46  -.41    -.36  -.37  -.31  -.31   -.4  -.47
1904  -.54  -.61  -.31   -.3   -.6  -.47  -.61  -.36  -.45  -.43     -.2  -.25    -.43  -.44  -.52   -.4  -.48  -.36
1905  -.41  -.86  -.16  -.15  -.12  -.22  -.33  -.23  -.28  -.35     .09  -.17    -.27  -.27   -.5  -.14  -.26  -.18
1906  -.23  -.24  -.41   .11  -.17  -.06  -.09  -.08  -.28  -.04    -.31  -.06    -.16  -.17  -.22  -.15  -.08  -.21
1907  -.38  -.51  -.34   -.4  -.47  -.45  -.29  -.43   -.3  -.26     -.5   -.6    -.41  -.37  -.32   -.4  -.39  -.35
1908  -.32  -.17  -.48  -.33  -.18  -.32   -.2  -.28  -.14  -.41    -.59  -.33    -.31  -.33  -.36  -.33  -.26  -.38
1909  -.71  -.43  -.43  -.57  -.41   -.2  -.19  -.12  -.21  -.09    -.06  -.45    -.32  -.31  -.49  -.47  -.17  -.12
1910  -.27  -.17  -.37  -.08  -.13  -.27  -.09  -.09   .01  -.25    -.41  -.59    -.23  -.21  -.29  -.19  -.15  -.22
1911  -.55  -.53   -.5   -.4  -.25   -.3  -.09  -.19  -.16  -.17     .02  -.19    -.27  -.31  -.55  -.38  -.19   -.1
1912  -.13  -.12  -.45  -.21  -.19  -.23  -.41  -.58  -.44  -.47     -.5  -.29    -.34  -.33  -.15  -.28  -.41  -.47
1913  -.36  -.49  -.45  -.18  -.61  -.53  -.25  -.21  -.18  -.21    -.05   .04    -.29  -.32  -.38  -.41  -.33  -.14
1914   .17   .01   .07  -.19   .01  -.04  -.08  -.01  -.05   .12    -.21  -.15    -.03  -.01   .07  -.03  -.04  -.05
1915  -.08   .14   .03   .08   .01  -.02   .18  -.03   .13   .01     .15  -.05     .05   .04  -.03   .04   .04    .1
1916   .02  -.04  -.34  -.19  -.21  -.25  -.21  -.03  -.11  -.15    -.36  -.73    -.22  -.16  -.02  -.25  -.17   -.2
1917   -.5  -.72   -.7  -.47  -.72  -.41   .16  -.34  -.31  -.45    -.33  -.88    -.47  -.46  -.65  -.63   -.2  -.36
1918  -.55  -.48  -.44  -.41  -.63  -.25  -.42   -.4  -.15   .04    -.19  -.24    -.34   -.4  -.63  -.49  -.36   -.1
1919  -.24  -.15  -.06  -.04  -.04  -.02   .05  -.04  -.13   .06    -.33  -.25     -.1   -.1  -.21  -.05    .0  -.13
1920  -.01  -.17   -.1   .02  -.21  -.23   .01  -.08  -.15  -.37    -.25  -.42    -.16  -.15  -.14   -.1   -.1  -.26
1921   .13  -.12  -.02    .0  -.11   .05   .13  -.31  -.08  -.05     -.2  -.12    -.06  -.08  -.14  -.04  -.04  -.11
1922  -.28   -.3  -.19   .11  -.24  -.17   .11  -.13  -.04  -.14    -.01  -.04    -.11  -.12  -.23  -.11  -.06  -.06
1923  -.16  -.18  -.14  -.35  -.14  -.21  -.37  -.26  -.26  -.01     .05   .05    -.16  -.17  -.13  -.21  -.28  -.07
1924  -.23  -.35  -.04  -.33  -.15  -.05   .01  -.03   .05  -.08    -.02  -.22    -.12   -.1  -.17  -.17  -.02  -.02
1925  -.32   -.3   -.2  -.05  -.23  -.29  -.26  -.03  -.29  -.23     .07   .27    -.16   -.2  -.28  -.16  -.19  -.15
1926   .28   .33    .2  -.02  -.21  -.11  -.05   .09   .07  -.07     .12  -.22     .03   .07   .29  -.01  -.02   .04
1927   -.1  -.11  -.27  -.23  -.17  -.15   .07  -.19   .01   .25     .26  -.14    -.07  -.07  -.14  -.22  -.09   .17
1928   .15   .12    .0   .02  -.31  -.43   .02   .04   .09    .0     .12   .05    -.01  -.03   .04   -.1  -.12   .07
1929  -.26  -.38  -.29  -.32  -.29  -.31  -.24  -.27  -.16    .1     .08  -.49    -.24  -.19   -.2   -.3  -.27    .0
1930  -.18  -.01   .06  -.16    .0  -.14  -.01  -.05  -.12  -.13     .22   .03    -.04  -.08  -.22  -.03  -.07  -.01
1931  -.02   -.2   .06  -.12  -.08   .08   .21   .19  -.08   .12    -.03    .2     .03   .01  -.06  -.05   .16    .0
1932   .51   -.1  -.03   .22  -.02  -.31  -.05  -.09   .14   .19      .0  -.06     .03   .06    .2   .06  -.15   .11
1933   -.2  -.08  -.08  -.07  -.05  -.12   .03  -.13  -.02   .01    -.27  -.41    -.12  -.09  -.11  -.07  -.08  -.09
1934  -.02   .07  -.19  -.23   .17  -.03   .17   .18    .0   .05     .16    .2     .05  -.01  -.12  -.08   .11   .07
1935   -.2   .34   .21  -.33  -.15  -.07  -.08  -.16  -.32   .04    -.18  -.07    -.08  -.06   .12  -.09   -.1  -.16
1936  -.14   -.3  -.08   .09  -.21  -.06   .33   .09   .05   .08      .1   .17     .01  -.01  -.17  -.07   .12   .08
1937   .01   .16  -.08  -.03   .11   .09   .04   .12   .28   .28     .36   .04     .11   .12   .11    .0   .08   .31
1938    .1   .12    .3   .37   .17  -.04   .11  -.02   .12    .4     .17  -.04     .15   .15   .09   .28   .02   .23
1939   .07  -.03  -.25  -.07    .1   .01  -.02  -.19  -.09  -.07    -.11   .41    -.02  -.06    .0  -.07  -.07  -.09
1940  -.14   .11   .13   .09   .12   .22   .33   .12   .18   .06     .09   .29     .13   .14   .12   .11   .23   .11
1941   .13   .23  -.01   .07   .11   .19   .36   .12  -.17   .15     .02   .12     .11   .13   .22   .06   .22    .0
1942   .29   .04   .02   .04   .09   .09   .12    .1    .1   .01     .19   .13      .1    .1   .15   .05    .1    .1
1943  -.14   .14  -.09   .08  -.04  -.09   .18   -.2   .09   .34     .14   .28     .06   .05   .04  -.01  -.04   .19
1944    .4    .2   .15    .0  -.04  -.06   .11   .12   .26   .26     .07  -.09     .12   .15   .29   .03   .06    .2
1945   .08  -.07   .04   .22  -.24  -.22  -.13    .3    .1   .09    -.01  -.26    -.01   .01  -.03   .01  -.02   .06
1946   .08   .06  -.08   .14   .12  -.08   .14  -.04   .05  -.11     .01  -.22      .0    .0  -.04   .06    .0  -.02
1947    .0   .13   .23   .19   .07   .04   .09   .08   .04   .28     .26  -.07     .11    .1  -.03   .17   .07    .2
1948   .26  -.06  -.21  -.06   .06   .14  -.08  -.14  -.03   .01    -.14  -.13    -.03  -.03   .05  -.07  -.03  -.05
1949    .1  -.27  -.09  -.25   -.1  -.17    .0  -.11  -.02   .03    -.06  -.11    -.09  -.09   -.1  -.15   -.1  -.02
1950  -.22  -.26  -.06  -.18   -.2  -.07  -.06  -.27  -.12  -.15    -.33  -.12    -.17  -.17   -.2  -.15  -.13   -.2
1951  -.35  -.42  -.13  -.02   .09  -.08  -.06   .16   .04   .11     .09   .23    -.03  -.06   -.3  -.02    .0   .08
1952   .16   .16  -.08  -.01  -.08  -.01   .13   .17   .16   .02    -.15    .0     .04   .06   .18  -.06    .1   .01
1953   .13   .11   .21   .21   .07   .08   .03   .17   .12   .09     .07   .23     .13   .11   .08   .16    .1    .1
1954  -.26  -.04  -.06  -.11  -.16  -.15  -.21  -.17  -.17   .04     .23  -.07    -.09  -.07  -.02  -.11  -.18   .03
1955   .26  -.06  -.33  -.13  -.13  -.15  -.09   .03   -.1   .05     -.2  -.24    -.09  -.08   .05   -.2  -.07  -.08
1956  -.16  -.25  -.26  -.22  -.23  -.06  -.06  -.31  -.07  -.19    -.16  -.14    -.17  -.18  -.22  -.23  -.14  -.14
1957   -.1    .0   .01   .16   .12   .19  -.07   .15   .14   .02     .19   .23     .09   .05  -.08   .09   .09   .12
1958   .44   .26    .2   .14    .1  -.15   .15  -.08  -.07   .11     .11  -.07      .1   .12   .31   .15  -.03   .05
1959   .04   .06   .25   .14  -.01   .11   .09    .0  -.15  -.05    -.08   .09     .04   .03   .01   .13   .07  -.09
1960   .05   .28  -.45  -.22  -.14  -.06   -.1    .1   .06   .12     -.1    .2    -.02  -.03   .14  -.27  -.02   .03
1961    .1   .22   .06   .09   .23   .12   .01   .05   .18   .17     .08  -.14      .1   .13   .17   .13   .06   .14
1962   .06   .21    .1   .13  -.11    .1  -.11  -.07   .07   .05     .13   .03     .05   .04   .04   .04  -.03   .08
1963  -.02   .25   -.2  -.21  -.13   .03   .09   .22   .32   .07     .05    .0     .04   .04   .09  -.18   .11   .15
1964  -.05  -.16  -.29  -.37  -.38  -.13  -.01  -.27  -.39  -.31    -.18  -.33    -.24  -.21  -.07  -.35  -.14  -.29
1965  -.02  -.16   -.1  -.26  -.09   -.1  -.26  -.06   -.2  -.09    -.13  -.19    -.14  -.15  -.17  -.15  -.14  -.14
1966  -.22  -.07   .12  -.13   -.1  -.05   .11  -.08  -.05  -.25    -.04  -.08    -.07  -.08  -.16  -.04  -.01  -.11
1967  -.06  -.27   .01  -.07   .14  -.13   .06   .02   .03   .16     .01  -.01    -.01  -.02  -.14   .03  -.01   .06
1968  -.18  -.16   .24   -.1  -.15  -.08  -.12  -.07  -.27   .06    -.08  -.24     -.1  -.08  -.12    .0  -.09  -.09
1969  -.19  -.27  -.13   .15   .12    .1  -.09  -.07   .01   .05     .07   .32     .01  -.04  -.23   .04  -.02   .04
1970   .08   .28   .09   .04  -.07   .09   .06   -.1   .16   .06     .01  -.13     .05   .08   .23   .02   .02   .07
1971  -.06  -.16  -.23  -.09  -.11  -.26   -.1   .05   .01  -.03    -.12  -.13     -.1   -.1  -.12  -.14   -.1  -.05
1972  -.35  -.33  -.08  -.07  -.05   .06   .01    .2   .05  -.09    -.09   .12    -.05  -.07  -.27  -.07   .09  -.04
1973   .23   .31   .31   .34   .28   .23   .17   .05   .08   .17     .07  -.05     .18    .2   .22   .31   .15   .11
1974  -.07  -.26  -.04  -.11    .0    .0    .0   .12  -.13  -.06    -.08  -.05    -.06  -.06  -.13  -.05   .04  -.09
1975   .05   .04   .14    .0   .27   .02  -.02  -.23  -.05  -.08    -.15  -.24    -.02  -.01   .01   .14  -.08   -.1
1976  -.07  -.13  -.37  -.26  -.27  -.22  -.21  -.26  -.18   -.4    -.23  -.07    -.22  -.24  -.15   -.3  -.23  -.27
1977    .1   .21   .23   .24    .3   .27   .24   .27  -.14  -.09     .15   .07     .15   .14   .08   .26   .26  -.03
1978   .06   .14   .22   .21   .17  -.03   .15  -.24   .09  -.03     .05   .03     .07   .07   .09    .2  -.04   .04
1979   .11  -.14    .2   .19  -.08   .13  -.02   .05   .17   .19     .24   .46     .12   .09    .0    .1   .05    .2
1980    .3   .35   .35   .35   .42   .14   .26   .22   .28   .13     .25   .16     .27   .29   .37   .38    .2   .22
1981   .59   .54   .59   .45   .27   .34   .51   .55   .23   .07     .19   .43      .4   .37   .43   .44   .47   .16
1982   .08    .2   -.1   .03   .28   .04   .15    .0  -.03  -.02      .1   .34     .09    .1   .24   .07   .06   .02
1983   .45   .39   .38   .34   .46   .26   .19   .51   .49   .19      .3   .17     .34   .36   .39   .39   .32   .33
1984    .2   .08   .31   .08   .48  -.08    .2   .23   .22   .17     .07  -.04     .16   .18   .15   .29   .12   .15
1985   .26  -.01   .21   .14   .09    .2   .02   .35   .18   .08     .01   .08     .14   .13   .07   .15   .19   .09
1986    .3   .49   .31   .32   .18   .08    .1   .18   .01   .04     .03   .12     .18   .18   .29   .27   .12   .03
1987   .35    .5   .23   .38   .25   .44   .48   .11   .28   .31     .29   .48     .34   .31   .32   .29   .35   .29
1988    .6   .38    .6   .42   .57   .52   .34   .36   .45   .46     .08   .28     .42   .44   .49   .53   .41   .33
1989   .13   .36   .31   .26    .1   .11   .37   .46   .48    .3     .11   .34     .28   .27   .26   .22   .31    .3
1990   .47   .38   .85   .63   .45   .41   .62    .4   .19   .53     .56   .43     .49   .49    .4   .64   .48   .43
1991   .43   .48    .4   .62   .35   .63   .67   .51   .43   .25     .23   .26     .44   .45   .45   .46   .61    .3
1992   .45   .42   .47   .21   .16   .26   .01   .08  -.15  -.05     -.1   .16     .16   .17   .38   .28   .11   -.1
1993   .31    .3   .37   .26   .21   .09   .18   .16   .01   .18     .03   .09     .18   .19   .26   .28   .14   .07
1994   .37   .08   .24   .35   .21   .53   .31   .12   .46    .4     .34   .33     .31   .29   .18   .26   .32    .4
1995   .44   .73   .42   .48   .18   .33    .7   .43   .36   .57     .42   .29     .45   .45    .5   .36   .49   .45
1996   .33   .43   .35   .19   .27   .17   .48   .49   .29   .28     .39   .37     .34   .33   .35   .27   .38   .32
1997   .38   .48   .52    .3   .26   .48    .2   .32   .26   .36      .5    .5     .38   .37   .41   .36   .33   .37
1998   .59   .93   .69    .8   .76   .71    .8   .71   .43   .53     .53   .69     .68   .66   .67   .75   .74    .5
1999    .5   .71   .27   .35   .28   .43   .37   .43   .38    .4     .34   .34      .4   .43   .63    .3   .41   .38
2000    .1   .61   .39   .57   .31   .51   .41   .18   .45   .11     .24    .3     .35   .35   .35   .43   .36   .27

2016 version :

           GLOBAL Temperature Anomalies in deg C    base period: 1951-1980
     
                  sources: GHCN-v3 1880-01/2016 (meteorological stations only)
                    using elimination of outliers and homogeneity adjustment
                    Notes: 1941 DJF = Dec 1940 - Feb 1941 ;  ***** = missing
     
Year   Jan   Feb   Mar   Apr   May   Jun   Jul   Aug   Sep   Oct     Nov   Dec     J-D   D-N   DJF   MAM   JJA   SON
1880  -.75  -.32   -.4  -.59  -.29  -.42   -.4   .14  -.42   -.6    -.44  -.45    -.41     *     *  -.43  -.22  -.49
1881  -.69  -.54  -.28   -.2   .03 -1.05  -.46  -.18   -.3  -.42     -.5  -.08    -.39  -.42  -.56  -.15  -.56  -.41
1882   .17  -.06  -.03  -.53  -.32  -.97  -.64  -.06  -.02  -.26    -.34  -.61     -.3  -.26   .01  -.29  -.56   -.2
1883  -.62  -.89   -.4  -.26   -.3    .5   .06  -.09  -.39  -.51    -.63  -.32    -.32  -.34   -.7  -.32   .16  -.51
1884  -.53  -.28  -.34  -.88 -1.14  -.76  -.78   .21   -.3  -.71    -.75  -.92     -.6  -.55  -.38  -.78  -.44  -.59
1885  -.86  -.73  -.85  -.81  -.44  -.88  -.54  -.11  -.09   .02    -.33   .08    -.46  -.55  -.84   -.7  -.51  -.13
1886  -.71  -.77  -.63  -.55   -.5  -.78  -.33  -.69  -.36  -.81    -.44  -.68     -.6  -.54  -.47  -.56   -.6  -.54
1887  -.79 -1.19  -.51  -.77  -.79   -.6  -.33  -.19  -.56  -.47    -.85  -.58    -.64  -.64  -.89  -.69  -.37  -.62
1888  -.74  -.79  -.84  -.26   -.7  -.51  -.29  -.32  -.36  -.26    -.07  -.19    -.44  -.48   -.7   -.6  -.37  -.23
1889  -.28   .18   .08   .15   .09  -.23  -.42   -.6  -.36   -.2    -.43  -.38     -.2  -.18  -.09   .11  -.42  -.33
1890  -.56   -.6   -.6  -.53  -.91  -.55  -.58  -.59  -.32  -.25    -.73  -.49    -.56  -.55  -.51  -.68  -.57  -.43
1891  -.94 -1.03  -.51  -.67  -.48  -.55  -.71  -.57  -.49  -.57    -.55   .04    -.59  -.63  -.82  -.55  -.61  -.54
1892   -.6  -.29  -.58  -.69  -.64  -.55  -.33  -.23  -.44  -.31     -.6  -.57    -.49  -.43  -.28  -.64  -.37  -.45
1893  -1.4  -.97  -.57  -.63  -.71  -.65  -.11  -.33  -.24  -.07    -.12  -.35    -.51  -.53  -.98  -.64  -.36  -.14
1894  -.83   -.6  -.39  -.62  -.64  -.47  -.35  -.28  -.42  -.07    -.14  -.15    -.41  -.43  -.59  -.55  -.37  -.21
1895  -.67  -.77  -.49  -.45  -.29  -.27  -.49  -.18  -.11  -.07    -.14  -.05    -.33  -.34  -.53  -.41  -.31   -.1
1896  -.21  -.27  -.51  -.46  -.44  -.45  -.19  -.35  -.08   .02    -.43  -.19     -.3  -.28  -.18  -.47  -.33  -.16
1897  -.23  -.49  -.31   -.1  -.26  -.17   -.1  -.31  -.14  -.21    -.02  -.24    -.22  -.21  -.31  -.23  -.19  -.12
1898  -.11  -.45  -.81  -.58  -.64   -.3  -.36  -.26  -.05  -.42    -.47  -.21    -.39  -.39  -.27  -.68  -.31  -.32
1899  -.43   -.6   -.4  -.26  -.42  -.55   -.3  -.29  -.02  -.29    -.03  -.22    -.32  -.32  -.41  -.36  -.38  -.12
1900  -.54  -.03  -.18  -.17  -.16  -.12  -.34  -.17  -.07   .16    -.11  -.06    -.15  -.16  -.26  -.17  -.21    .0
1901  -.23  -.11  -.12  -.09  -.23   .01  -.24   -.2   .03  -.18    -.14  -.21    -.14  -.13  -.13  -.15  -.15  -.09
1902  -.32  -.04  -.19   -.2  -.32  -.39  -.47  -.52  -.41  -.47     -.5  -.56    -.37  -.34  -.19  -.24  -.46  -.46
1903  -.36  -.15  -.19  -.57  -.47  -.65  -.32  -.44  -.43   -.5    -.49  -.63    -.43  -.43  -.36  -.41  -.47  -.47
1904   -.8  -.76  -.57  -.46  -.66  -.49  -.62  -.51  -.45  -.53    -.26   -.4    -.54  -.56  -.73  -.56  -.54  -.41
1905  -.43  -1.0  -.25  -.32  -.37  -.33  -.44  -.31  -.25  -.38    -.09  -.27    -.37  -.38  -.61  -.31  -.36  -.24
1906  -.19  -.38  -.37   .04  -.21  -.23  -.22  -.19   -.3  -.19    -.55  -.27    -.26  -.26  -.28  -.18  -.21  -.35
1907  -.51  -.69  -.47  -.63  -.61  -.67  -.42  -.57   -.4  -.34    -.61  -.66    -.55  -.52  -.49  -.57  -.55  -.45
1908  -.38  -.33  -.54  -.47  -.34  -.44   -.4  -.42  -.18  -.43    -.61  -.42    -.41  -.43  -.46  -.45  -.42  -.41
1909  -.79   -.6  -.51  -.62  -.59  -.42  -.35  -.11  -.21  -.19    -.18  -.54    -.43  -.42   -.6  -.57  -.29  -.19
1910  -.48   -.4  -.47  -.33  -.28  -.35  -.22  -.14   -.1   -.3    -.53  -.67    -.36  -.35  -.47  -.36  -.24  -.31
1911  -.66  -.67  -.61  -.52  -.39  -.38  -.18  -.26  -.26  -.17    -.14  -.26    -.38  -.41  -.67  -.51  -.27  -.19
1912  -.21  -.14  -.43   -.3  -.21  -.26  -.49  -.62  -.35  -.47    -.45  -.32    -.36  -.35   -.2  -.31  -.46  -.43
1913  -.43  -.49  -.59  -.32  -.63   -.6  -.23   -.2  -.19  -.29    -.16   .04    -.34  -.37  -.41  -.51  -.34  -.21
1914   .15  -.04  -.05  -.19  -.03  -.07  -.21  -.08  -.08   .14    -.32  -.21    -.08  -.06   .05  -.09  -.12  -.09
1915  -.18   .04  -.09  -.03  -.21  -.19   .06  -.18   .03  -.08     .06   -.1    -.07  -.08  -.12  -.11   -.1    .0
1916   -.1  -.12  -.43  -.29  -.35  -.47  -.34  -.11  -.15  -.15    -.39  -.78    -.31  -.25  -.11  -.36  -.31  -.23
1917  -.52  -.73  -.81  -.54   -.8  -.45   .02  -.38  -.31  -.47    -.34  -.91    -.52  -.51  -.68  -.72  -.27  -.37
1918  -.63  -.61  -.51  -.55  -.76  -.42  -.47  -.47  -.19   .03    -.26  -.33    -.43  -.48  -.72  -.61  -.45  -.14
1919  -.28  -.27  -.14  -.15  -.17  -.17  -.07  -.08  -.21  -.05    -.42  -.29    -.19   -.2  -.29  -.16  -.11  -.23
1920  -.12  -.32  -.25  -.21  -.37  -.37   -.2  -.18  -.19  -.43    -.33  -.47    -.29  -.27  -.24  -.27  -.25  -.32
1921  -.03   -.2  -.12   -.2  -.21  -.11   .02  -.45  -.16  -.12     -.3  -.18    -.17   -.2  -.23  -.18  -.18  -.19
1922  -.41  -.45  -.32  -.12  -.42  -.32  -.07  -.27  -.17  -.27    -.12  -.17    -.26  -.26  -.35  -.28  -.22  -.19
1923  -.29  -.24  -.23  -.52  -.34  -.32  -.51  -.38  -.31  -.12    -.03  -.06    -.28  -.29  -.23  -.36   -.4  -.15
1924  -.26  -.42  -.15  -.51  -.29  -.17  -.17  -.17   -.1  -.16    -.08   -.3    -.23  -.21  -.25  -.32  -.17  -.11
1925  -.45  -.39   -.3  -.18  -.37  -.43  -.41  -.11   -.3  -.34    -.03   .18    -.26   -.3  -.38  -.28  -.32  -.22
1926   .24   .29    .2  -.12  -.38  -.23  -.17   .01   .01  -.14     .01  -.27    -.05  -.01   .24   -.1  -.13  -.04
1927  -.19  -.17  -.37  -.37  -.31  -.28  -.09  -.29  -.12   .15     .08  -.25    -.19  -.19  -.21  -.35  -.22   .04
1928   .03  -.01  -.12  -.13   -.4  -.54  -.05  -.05   .02  -.05     .06  -.07    -.11  -.12  -.08  -.22  -.21   .01
1929  -.29  -.48  -.38  -.44  -.42  -.43  -.38  -.39  -.21    .0    -.08   -.6    -.34   -.3  -.28  -.41   -.4   -.1
1930  -.23  -.19  -.07  -.21  -.17  -.23   -.2   -.2  -.15  -.29     .09  -.08    -.16   -.2  -.34  -.15  -.21  -.12
1931  -.13  -.27  -.07  -.28  -.18  -.09   .07   .08  -.18   .06    -.15   .08    -.09   -.1  -.16  -.18   .02  -.09
1932   .36  -.27  -.22   .03  -.23  -.47  -.23   -.2   .01   .06    -.11  -.17    -.12   -.1   .06  -.14   -.3  -.01
1933  -.33  -.25  -.22  -.19  -.15  -.27  -.14  -.21  -.12  -.08    -.39  -.54    -.24  -.21  -.25  -.19  -.21   -.2
1934  -.16  -.12  -.36  -.37  -.03   -.2  -.01   .03  -.09  -.07     .04   .11     -.1  -.16  -.27  -.25  -.06  -.04
1935  -.32   .21   .02  -.49  -.35  -.23  -.26  -.23   -.4  -.06    -.34  -.17    -.22   -.2    .0  -.28  -.24  -.27
1936  -.31  -.46   -.2  -.05   -.3  -.15   .22   .02    .0   .03     .04   .07    -.09  -.11  -.31  -.18   .03   .02
1937   -.1   .04  -.21   -.2  -.04  -.04  -.09   .04   .23   .18     .27  -.07      .0   .01    .0  -.15  -.03   .23
1938    .0   .02    .2   .24   .08  -.11   .01  -.07   .09   .32      .1  -.11     .07   .07  -.02   .18  -.06   .17
1939  -.01  -.14  -.36  -.17    .0  -.08  -.12  -.26  -.11  -.09    -.15   .35     -.1  -.13  -.09  -.18  -.15  -.12
1940  -.19   .08   .12   .01   .04   .15    .2   .08   .16   .04     .04   .22     .08   .09   .08   .06   .14   .08
1941   .02   .21  -.13  -.01   .08   .12   .27   .04   -.2   .09    -.05   .02     .04   .06   .15  -.02   .14  -.05
1942   .23  -.02  -.03  -.02   .02   .07   .06   .09   .07  -.01     .11   .07     .05   .05   .08  -.01   .07   .06
1943  -.19   .06  -.15   .02   -.1   -.1    .1  -.17   .05   .28     .09   .21     .01    .0  -.02  -.08  -.06   .14
1944   .33   .13    .1  -.07  -.07  -.11   .02   .05   .22   .22     .01  -.16     .06   .09   .22  -.01  -.01   .15
1945   .02  -.11  -.01   .12  -.27  -.29  -.22    .2   .04   .03    -.07  -.34    -.08  -.06  -.09  -.06  -.11    .0
1946   .02  -.03  -.15   .04   .02  -.15   .03  -.11    .0  -.17    -.07  -.27    -.07  -.08  -.12  -.03  -.08  -.08
1947  -.08   .06   .21   .14  -.01  -.04   .02   .01   .02   .25     .23  -.13     .06   .05   -.1   .12    .0   .16
1948   .22  -.14  -.28  -.13  -.02   .05  -.16  -.19  -.03  -.03    -.18  -.16    -.09  -.09  -.02  -.14   -.1  -.08
1949   .05  -.35  -.08  -.26   -.2  -.23  -.09  -.14  -.07    .0    -.07  -.13    -.13  -.13  -.15  -.18  -.16  -.04
1950  -.28  -.34  -.09  -.24  -.24  -.14  -.13  -.35  -.19  -.21    -.39  -.18    -.23  -.23  -.25  -.19  -.21  -.26
1951  -.37  -.46  -.17  -.06   .06  -.12  -.11    .1    .0   .05     .01   .15    -.08   -.1  -.34  -.05  -.04   .02
1952   .09   .12  -.17  -.07  -.13   -.1   .04   .09   .13  -.03    -.21  -.04    -.02  -.01   .12  -.12   .01  -.04
1953   .11   .07   .15    .1  -.03   .01  -.03    .1   .08   .06     .02   .15     .07   .05   .04   .07   .03   .05
1954  -.29  -.08  -.12  -.15   -.2  -.21  -.26  -.17  -.17   .01     .18   -.1    -.13  -.11  -.07  -.16  -.22   .01
1955   .24  -.09  -.36  -.16  -.14  -.17  -.13   .14  -.12   .02    -.25  -.28    -.11  -.09   .02  -.22  -.05  -.11
1956  -.23  -.31  -.32  -.26  -.27   -.1   -.1  -.32   -.1  -.22    -.21  -.18    -.22  -.23  -.27  -.28  -.17  -.18
1957  -.13  -.06  -.08   .03  -.01   .15  -.09    .2   .13  -.01     .15   .18     .04   .01  -.12  -.02   .08   .09
1958   .38   .23   .17    .1   .11   -.2   .04  -.13   -.1   .07     .07  -.08     .05   .08   .26   .13   -.1   .01
1959   .03   .07   .25   .19  -.01   .09   .08    .0  -.12   -.1     -.1    .1     .04   .02   .01   .14   .06  -.11
1960   .08   .26  -.47  -.21  -.15  -.02  -.12   .08   .07   .13     -.1   .18    -.02  -.03   .15  -.28  -.02   .03
1961   .09   .23   .04   .14   .19   .08  -.01   .04   .16   .08     .07  -.14     .08   .11   .17   .12   .04    .1
1962   .07   .16   .09   .06  -.11   .04  -.12  -.08  -.01    .0     .08    .0     .01    .0   .03   .01  -.06   .02
1963  -.02   .22  -.24  -.19  -.14   .01   .06   .15   .21   .07     .05  -.07     .01   .02   .07  -.19   .07   .11
1964  -.07  -.17   -.3  -.37  -.35  -.16  -.08  -.33  -.36  -.34    -.21  -.34    -.26  -.23   -.1  -.34  -.19  -.31
1965  -.06  -.18  -.13  -.29  -.16  -.18  -.24  -.09  -.24  -.11    -.13   -.2    -.17  -.18  -.19  -.19  -.17  -.16
1966  -.25  -.04   .12  -.11  -.09  -.02    .1  -.13  -.05  -.27    -.07  -.08    -.07  -.08  -.16  -.03  -.02  -.13
1967  -.09  -.25   .01   -.1   .15  -.12   .04   .03  -.01   .11     .01  -.01    -.02  -.02  -.14   .02  -.02   .04
1968   -.2  -.16   .32  -.09  -.18   -.1  -.12  -.09  -.29   .05    -.08  -.22     -.1  -.08  -.12   .02   -.1  -.11
1969  -.17  -.26  -.09    .1   .13   .02  -.03   -.1   .01   .06     .08   .34     .01  -.04  -.22   .05  -.04   .05
1970   .05   .27   .11   .12  -.06   .14   .08  -.07   .15    .1     .03  -.11     .07    .1   .22   .05   .05   .09
1971  -.03  -.15  -.21  -.06  -.07  -.21  -.11   .03   .04  -.03    -.12  -.06    -.08  -.08   -.1  -.11  -.09  -.04
1972  -.32  -.31  -.06  -.07  -.01   .08   .05   .19   .06  -.04    -.07   .14    -.03  -.05  -.23  -.05   .11  -.02
1973   .25   .32   .36   .35   .35    .3   .22   .07   .12   .21      .1  -.02     .22   .23   .24   .35    .2   .14
1974  -.04  -.22    .0  -.07   .03   .04  -.01   .14  -.15  -.06    -.06  -.04    -.04  -.03  -.09  -.01   .06  -.09
1975   .09    .1   .16   .05   .28   .07   .08  -.25  -.01  -.03    -.06  -.22     .02   .04   .05   .16  -.03  -.03
1976  -.01  -.07   -.3  -.22  -.24  -.17  -.14  -.22  -.15  -.37    -.17  -.03    -.17  -.19   -.1  -.25  -.18  -.23
1977   .13   .23   .31   .31   .31   .33    .3   .31  -.08   .01     .25   .15     .21    .2   .11   .31   .31   .06
1978   .13   .18   .28   .25   .21   .06    .2  -.16   .17   .05     .17   .11     .14   .14   .16   .24   .03   .13
1979   .18  -.09   .24    .2   .08   .23   .04   .13   .29   .28     .31   .54      .2   .17   .07   .17   .13   .29
1980   .36   .45   .42   .46   .47   .23   .37   .33   .35   .23     .28   .17     .34   .37   .45   .45   .31   .29
1981   .61   .57   .68    .5   .31   .39   .51   .52   .29   .13     .25   .49     .44   .41   .45    .5   .48   .22
1982   .13   .26  -.02   .02   .25   .03   .19   .09    .1   .02     .11    .4     .13   .14   .29   .08    .1   .08
1983    .5   .41   .47    .4   .49   .29   .21   .48   .57   .32     .33   .17     .39   .41   .44   .45   .33   .41
1984   .25   .16   .38   .17   .48   .05   .18   .28   .27   .23      .1   .03     .22   .23    .2   .34   .17    .2
1985   .31   .05   .26   .19   .23   .28   .06   .35   .26   .16      .1   .16      .2   .19   .13   .23   .23   .17
1986   .38    .5   .37   .42   .32   .15   .15   .19   .01   .12     .11    .2     .24   .24   .34   .37   .17   .08
1987   .43   .53   .24   .39   .29   .55   .59   .25   .35   .35      .3   .56      .4   .37   .39   .31   .46   .33
1988   .66   .48   .56   .49   .62   .58   .44   .55   .54   .51     .14   .35     .49   .51   .56   .55   .53    .4
1989   .28   .45   .46   .42   .22   .18   .46   .51   .53   .44     .21   .38     .38   .38   .36   .37   .38   .39
1990   .51   .42   .86   .62   .52   .46   .62   .43    .3   .52     .52   .46     .52   .51   .43   .67    .5   .45
1991   .48   .61   .47   .71   .43    .7   .63   .56   .61   .34     .32   .34     .52   .53   .52   .54   .63   .43
1992    .5   .43   .54   .23   .26   .29   .08   .14  -.06   .07     .02   .25     .23   .24   .42   .34   .17   .01
1993   .38   .41   .34    .3   .27   .26   .38   .22    .1   .22     .09   .21     .27   .27   .35    .3   .29   .14
1994   .39   .08   .25   .52   .25   .56    .4   .23   .44   .41     .51   .43     .37   .35   .23   .34    .4   .45
1995   .56   .89    .5   .58   .38   .51   .63   .58   .46   .67     .52    .4     .56   .56   .63   .49   .57   .55
1996   .41    .6   .45   .48   .34   .33   .55   .77   .41   .33     .49   .52     .47   .46   .47   .42   .55   .41
1997   .47   .54   .65   .38   .42   .66   .34   .43    .5    .6     .71   .69     .53   .52   .51   .48   .48    .6
1998   .71  1.19   .82   .83   .94  1.04   .91   .87    .6   .68     .65   .81     .84   .83   .87   .87   .94   .64
1999   .68   .87   .48   .43   .49   .63   .65   .55   .67   .63     .58   .53      .6   .62   .79   .47   .61   .63
2000   .31   .79   .69   .76   .56   .69   .63    .6   .57   .34     .48   .47     .57   .58   .54   .67   .64   .46
2001   .59   .64   .69   .62   .73   .66   .71   .66    .7   .62     .84   .73     .68   .66   .57   .68   .67   .72
2002   .97   .91  1.12    .8   .87   .66   .82   .69   .82   .64     .69   .54     .79   .81   .87   .93   .72   .71
2003   .91   .74   .71   .69   .87   .64   .65   .86   .83   .89     .66   .85     .77   .75   .73   .76   .72   .79
2004   .71   .92   .85   .76   .48   .64   .24   .58   .59   .83     .87   .67     .68   .69   .83    .7   .49   .76
2005   .97   .88   .93   .84   .75   .82    .8   .75   .96   .99      .9   .89     .87   .85   .84   .84   .79   .95
2006   .74   .93   .81   .67    .5   .77   .68   .83   .72   .84     .87   .93     .77   .77   .85   .66   .76   .81
2007  1.23   .92   .91   .93   .94   .66   .78   .86   .82    .8     .69    .7     .85   .87  1.02   .93   .77   .77
2008   .49   .44   .91   .66   .57   .52   .72    .4    .8   .74      .8   .72     .65   .64   .54   .71   .54   .78
2009   .75   .76   .65   .75   .79   .82   .86   .86   .91   .73     .85   .75     .79   .79   .74   .73   .85   .83
2010   .95  1.04  1.13  1.01   .96   .86   .74   .83   .88   .96     1.0    .7     .92   .93   .92  1.03   .81   .94
2011   .73   .66   .77   .84   .65   .74   .91   .96   .78   .85     .78   .79     .79   .78    .7   .75   .87    .8
2012   .61   .58   .71    .8   .96   .71   .58   .86    .9   .95     .94   .72     .78   .78   .66   .82   .72   .93
2013   .98   .78   .86   .67   .68   .88   .66   .79   .99   .86     .87   .84     .82   .81   .82   .73   .78   .91
2014   .95   .64    .8   .89  1.04   .77   .73   .86  1.07  1.04     .82   .97     .88   .87   .81   .91   .79   .98
2015   .94  1.07   1.1   .79   .88   .86   .77   .86   .81  1.18    1.21  1.42     .99   .95   1.0   .92   .83  1.07
2016  1.34     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *       *     *       *     *     *     *     *     *

After predicting a Clinton landslide, fake news CNN now says Trump barely won.

You really can’t make this stuff up.

In 1973, glaciers were growing and animals were migrating south from the cold.

“The Ice Age Cometh” The Saturday Review, Saturday, March 24th, 1973

The National Center for Atmospheric Research and CRU both reported a very strong cooling trend since WWII.

14 Jul 1974, Page 1 – Lincoln Evening Journal

In 1981, James Hansen at NASA still showed much of the post-WWII cooling trend, as well as a Medieval Warm Period, Little Ice Age and a 7,000 year long global cooling trend.

Challenge_chapter2.pdf

Gavin Schmidt at NASA has since completely removed this cooling trend, and now shows warming from 1945 to 1975.

graph.png (1130×600)

CSV

Gavin didn’t do this tampering all at once. It has been a 16 year long project where he has tripled global warming by altering the data set.

Link to NASA files  2016  2012  2000

What is truly stunning is that satellite measured temperatures of the troposphere show little or no warming during that 16 year period when Gavin tripled global warming.

Wood for Trees: Interactive Graphs

The people in the tiny blue areas say that Trump is not their president. As magnanimous winners, we should give them exactly what they want. Let’s turn the blue areas into sanctuary cities with no fossil fuels, no free speech, high taxes, corrupt government and no right to defend themselves from their fellow Democrats.

After being angry for eight years about having to wake up in the White House every day, Michelle is now angry about losing her job to a legal immigrant.

Believe it or not, there are actually morons out there who believe an increase of 0.0001 mole fraction CO2 over the past century somehow threatens our survival. And they believe that 97% of scientists agree with their idiocy.

CIA investigations apparently require no actual investigation.

The war on America by the MSM is in full swing now.

Congress shall make no law ….. prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

First Amendment To The US Constitution